Peter Greenaway asks is cinema dead? (A nightcap work in progress)

Peter Greenaway This is a piece I've been sitting on for a while. It's not a fully formed piece rather its a series of comments made in reaction to a recorded lecture by Peter Greenaway. I've been trying to bang it into a proper essay but I can't get it to work. I'm tired of looking at it so I'm now going to turn it loose and let you ponder it. I may revisit it since I was recently given another Greenaway lecture given about the same time but twice as long and it may inspire me to run by this material again.

The photos are courtesy of Lou Macaluso and were taken at the Park Avenue Armory when Greenaway's Last Supper was there in December 2010.

In a speech given in Australia not long before the release of Nightwatching Peter Greenaway rails on about the death of cinema. It’s a claim, that he himself will freely admit is a contradiction since he himself is , amongst other things, a filmmaker. The lecture, given at the Perth Documentary Film Conference, was given to me as a bonus disc with a new copy of the Tulse Luper Suitcase films. It’s one of the earliest statements I’ve seen on video of Greenaway’s battle cry of cinema being dead.

I’m not so sure that cinema is dead. To be certain the way we see film is changing. We are going to fewer movies, we are watching more at home, but don’t think anything is dead.

I think Greenaway’s problem is a matter of semantics.

What exactly does he think cinema is? Is he talking about the typical film simple narrative projected on a wall?

As a narrative form it’s something that is constantly evolving. How we see films is forever changing and evolving. We have trans-media which Lincoln Center is constantly exploring with its multi-platform conferences and screenings.

Is the projection of images dead? No.

Greenaway complains how we see a film must change. Change the screen, change the venue, change way the image is delivered. Having seen what he has done to change this I agree. He makes some truly spectacular presentations, but they are highly impractical for anything but a communal or experience outside of the home.

I think Greenaway is arguing that how we experience film outside of the home has to change. However at the same time he has to realize that what he is doing in the museums and armories and other locations will never ever translate except to those singular spaces.

-

Greenaway talks of the Luper films being cut up and jumbled and all projected at the same time as a sort of VJ experience. Strip away the soundtrack and just use music. While I like the idea of image and music what then becomes the purpose of a narrative film?

His cries of doing away with text are contradiction since any sort of film – short of just shooting random images –are tied to text. Greenaway’s own work are filled with text not only in the dialog and script but within the images which brims with words over images.

Cries of doing away with text are the cries of a painter (Greenaway was trained as one) since painting like most art form as are the creative representation of emotion and ideas.

Yours truly (left) watches the Last Supper come to life ala Greenaway
Cinema dead?

Not really.

The narrative form is despite Greenaway’s dislike of it is thriving.

His arguments that the screen as we know it is dead may very well be- but the real problem is that the in order to tell stories visually to the masses you have to have some standardizations. Yes you can blow it apart but mostly you need something standard so that the stories and experiences can travel as they must- you want to reach as many people as possible and not just a chosen few.

The ability to display images in a variety of different manner has been around as long as films. Yes with the increase of TV and technology the size and shapes have changed, but Greenaway has to face the same problems that avante garde and art filmmakers have faced over the last 100 or so years- the shifting image sizes and shapes will limit what you are doing- making things too radical will kill the art form not faster than the limitations of standardization ever will...

Peter Greenaway meets his public (That's my balding head center)Posted bySteve Kopianat10:16 PM

Labels:essay,nightcap,peter greenawayNo comments:Post a Comment

Newer PostOlder PostHomeSubscribe to:Post Comments (Atom)ContributorsRegchockoRandiFrank GrimesBullymondo_curryKen FriesPeter GutierezSteve KopianJohn DiBelloEdenmr c

Film FestivalsBrooklyn Academyof MusicBrooklyn Film FestivalDOC NYCFilm Society of Lincoln Center and The New York Film FestivalJapan SocietyKorean American Film Festival New YorkKorean Cultural ServiceNew York City Horror Film FestivalNew York International Children's Film FestivalSeattle International Film FestivalSubway Cinema News and The New York Asian Film FestivalTribeca Film Festival

Also by Unseen ContributorsBully Says Comics Oughta Be FunComics GirlConnect the PopEden's Daily HaikuEden's Food BlogMark of ContemptPlanet ChockoViolent Eye ReportYou Otter Know

Film FriendsBullets Over ChinatowncineAwesomefilmsRrussMy Life at 24 Frames Per SecondNutshell Reviews

Useful Film Links10,000 BulletsDigital Fix UK (What's new and what's good)Drew McWeeneyDVD Beaver (DVD reviews and comparisons)DVD Drive-inFlixistKoreanfilm.orgNew Korean CinemaRoger Ebert

Not Your Usual Collection of Movie SourcesA Few Words on the SourcesAll Clues No SolutionsAsian Cult Cinema MagazineDiabolik DVDOldies,com (Alpha Video)R & B EnterprisesSinister CinemaYes Asia

Because life is more than moviesCake or Death? (Auntie Momo's Eddie Izzard`Fan site)Creatures of DelightImaginism StudiosLate Life Musingsmimo studiosNow this Sound is Brave (a cool music blog)

Blog Archive▼ 2013(174)▼ March(45)Smokey and the Bandit (1977)Don’t Let ‘The Happy Poet’ Remain UnseenEmperor of the North Pole (1973)Imitation General (1958)Putting The Act of Killing: The Director's Cut (20...Broadway Melody (1929)Nightcap 3/24/13 Odds & ends and clearing the boar...The Woodsman (2004)Russia House (1990)Color of the Chamelon (2012) New Directors New FIi...The Emperor Visits Hell (2013) New Directors New F...BLOODY FIGHT IN IRON ROCK VALLEY is the next free ...Blue Caprice (2012) New Directors New Films 2013Pam Grier Grindhouse Triple Feature: BLACK MAMA WH...Pam Grier at Lincoln Center in image and videoPeter Greenaway asks is cinema dead? (A nightcap w...Poison Ivy (1953)The Big Bluff (1957)Chocko meets Pam GrierWho's afraid of Song of the South? And other Forbi...Treasure Planet (2002)Lincoln Center presents: Old Ghosts, New Dreams: T...Twice Upon a Time (1983)From Up on Poppy Hill (2011) NYICFF 2013 (revised)...Mouse and His Child (1977)Nightcap 3/10/13: God bless faded black and white ...Broadways Deadly Gold (1969)Suicide Shop at Rendez-Vous with French Cinema or...Death and Diamonds (1967)Tuesday at the free Korean Cultural Service screen...Murderers Club of Brooklyn (Dead Girl in Central P...Hey Krishna (2012) NYICFF 2013Tip Not Included (1966)NYICFF 2013: Shorts 2 and Heebie JeebiesTraps Snaps Shut at Midnight (1966)The Day of the Crows (2012) NYICFF 2013 and Rendez...Murder Night in Manhattan (1965)Ernest and Celestine (2012) NYICFF 2013Violin Case Murders (1965)It's not why doesn't Oscar notice horror, it's why...Neon Gen A Short Review (1995) An Animation on DVD...A Few Words on NYICFF Day 1 and 2 (Revised)Patlabor 1(1989) An Animation on DVD ReviewBrit Crime: Better on TV or Film? ‘The Sweeney’ an...Short Bus (2006) ► February(66) ► January(63) ► 2012(801) ► December(54) ► November(64) ► October(83) ► September(53) ► August(53) ► July(81) ► June(88) ► May(56) ► April(82) ► March(65) ► February(52) ► January(70) ► 2011(683) ► December(62) ► November(50) ► October(62) ► September(52) ► August(48) ► July(81) ► June(56) ► May(56) ► April(55) ► March(54) ► February(49) ► January(58) ► 2010(506) ► December(44) ► November(54) ► October(53) ► September(45) ► August(55) ► July(47) ► June(46) ► May(44) ► April(49) ► March(51) ► February(18)

Labels3D(15)7x7 award(1)acrtion(1)actio(1)action(152)adam curtis(5)adaptation(6)adult swim(1)adventure(53)africa(2)Alfred Hitchcock(1)ambivalent post(80)american(606)animation(111)animation on dvd(2)anime(6)anthology(1)architecture(1)argentina(1)art(8)asia(1)asia society(1)asian film(2)australia(14)austria(1)b-movie(2)balkan(1)BAM(8)bamkids fest(1)beyond the black rainbow(1)biography(25)black comedy(15)book(2)bosnia(1)bowery boys(5)boxing day(3)brazil(3)Britian(1)british(2)BrooklynFF(4)bruce lee(1)bulgaria(1)bully(21)buster keaton(13)cabaret(1)cambodia(2)canada(18)caper(2)capsule reviews(44)celebrity(1)chile(4)china(118)chinese new year 2012(14)chinese new year 2013(26)chocko(3)chow yun fat(2)christmas(8)christopher doyle(1)cineawesome(1)cinekink(1)cinemania(1)classic film(1)columbia(3)comedy(199)comic(59)contest(1)creatures(1)crime(135)criterion(1)crowdfunding(1)czech republic(1)dance(2)dave mckean(3)David Morrissey(1)daytime drinking(1)denmark(11)detachment(1)detective dee(1)dinosuars(1)disability(1)disney(4)DOCNYC 2012(22)documentary(294)donnie yen(1)drama(313)dvd(1)dvd extra(18)eddie constantine(7)eden(18)edgar and bryan wallace(10)editorial(1)egypt(3)eihi shiina(1)England(126)epic(5)essay(14)estonia(2)experimental(2)exploitation(8)fairy tale(2)fantasy(57)farce(1)fcs 2011(6)fcs 2012(1)festival(7)film comment selects(1)film comment selects 2012(1)film comment selects 2013(4)film festivals(1)film on film(4)filmlinc(3)Filmsruss(1)finland(8)first time fest(1)found footage(3)france(106)free(3)french(6)friars club comedy film festival(1)german(1)germany(66)Giallo(1)godspeed you black emperor(1)Gold Coast Film Festival(2)GSYBE(1)guatemala(1)Halloween(3)hammer(1)Heat(1)helldriver(3)hip hop(1)hiphop(2)historical drama(105)history(4)hoax(1)hong kong(44)horror(187)housekeeping(18)human rights watch 2012(2)hungary(4)iceland(4)independent(3)india(12)indonesia(6)interview(13)iran(2)ireland(6)Irish(4)israel(6)italian(4)italy(48)jackie chan(1)japan(180)japan cuts(24)japan cuts 2012(24)japan society(18)jerry cotton(7)john(24)john pilger(3)jonathan chance(1)kaffny(2)kaffny 2012(12)Karl Lemieux(1)kcs(58)ken(36)kickstarter(3)korea(130)korean american film festival(1)korean blogathon(3)korean blogathon 2012(14)korean cultural service(8)kuwait(1)latin beat 2012(1)latinbeat 2011(3)latvia(1)lemmy caution(3)let the bullets fly(1)lincoln center(26)lists(2)live performance(1)love will tear us apart(2)lovejoy(1)lucy mulloy(1)Luther(1)mad museum(1)made-for-tv(3)magic(2)malaysia(5)manga(4)Marathi(1)marriage(1)martial arts(10)mental illness(2)mexico(27)midnight movie(2)miike takashi(3)moebius(9)moma(1)mondocurry(84)mountie(4)mounties(4)Mr C(41)mst3k(24)mst3k material(2)murder(6)music(19)musical(63)mystery(115)ndnf 2011(5)ndnf 2012(10)ndnf 2013(5)nepal(1)Netherlands(7)new korean cinema(1)new york asian film festival(10)new york asian film festival 2012(11)new york comic con 2011(6)new york comic con 2012(1)New York Korean Film Festival(3)New York Korean Film Festival 2013(1)new yorker festival 2011(4)new zealand(2)nightcap(53)nishimura yoshihiro(3)noir(7)norrway(3)norway(2)not a movie(8)not on imdb(10)not worth the effort(34)nyaff(36)nyaff 2010(40)nyaff 2011(72)nyaff 2012(69)nyc(21)nycc 2010(6)nycc 2011(1)nycc 2012(5)nyccc 2012(1)nychff(11)nychff 2012(2)nyciff(2)nyff(10)nyff 2010(19)nyff 2011(48)nyff 2012(53)nyff50(4)nyicff(11)nyicff 2010(8)nyicff 2011(12)nyicff 2012(12)nyicff 2013(9)nyjff 2012(1)nyjff 2013(3)Oliver Stone(1)on further review(32)one armed swordsman(1)Open Roads 2012(6)Oscar Nominated films(1)pakistan(1)pam grier(4)panel(1)pen to paper(1)peter greenaway(5)Peter Gutierrez(7)philippines(9)philosophy(1)photos(2)pinku(2)poland(1)polemic(1)Polisse(1)politics(5)portugal(1)posters(1)production designer(1)psychological thriller(2)punk(3)puppets(3)q and a(4)Random Thoughts(1)reg(6)reign of assassins(1)religion(3)remake(14)Rendezvous with French Cinema 2012(5)Rendezvous with French Cinema 2013(5)renfrew(8)review(1)revisit(2)revist(1)ricky jay(1)robert(16)Robert Boyle(1)Robert De Niro(1)rock music(2)romance(73)romania(4)romantic comedy(5)russia(22)rwanda(1)RYOO Seung-wan(1)saiff 2012(5)samurai(3)san diego comic con(1)satire(6)scary movies(1)scary movies 5(3)scary movies 6(1)scenes of the crime blogathon(2)science fiction(125)scotland(2)segundo de chomon(1)serbia(2)serial(8)sex(1)shakespeare(9)Shaw Brothers(2)sherlock holmes(1)shorts(35)silent films(13)silverdocs(2)slasher(3)social issues(2)society(1)something like a phenomenon(1)sources(1)south africa(3)south korea(6)soviet(1)spain(18)spanish cinema now 2012(1)sports(18)spy(10)steampunk(1)subway cinema(39)suggested title(27)summer(1)sundance(1)sushi typhoon(2)suspense(4)sweden(6)swords and sandals(7)tae-kwon do(1)taiwan(19)tarantino(1)tarzan(6)television(1)Thai(15)thailand(2)theater(5)Thorne(1)thriller(48)tony kaye(1)trailer(25)trailers(2)trash(9)tribeca(25)tribeca 2011(32)tribeca 2012(70)tribeca talks(2)tsui hark(3)turkish(14)tv(7)twitter(2)una noche(1)underwater love(1)unseen turkey day(12)updates(56)Uruguay(1)V/H/S(1)vicious brothers(1)video(5)vietnam(2)wales(1)Walking Dead(1)walter reade theater(15)war(67)warner archive(15)warner brothers(1)welcome(1)wen jiang(1)Werner Herzog(7)western(37)wholphin(1)wip(3)women in prison(2)wrestling(2)wtf(77)wu xia(31)year end 2011(4)year end 2012(4)yugoslavia(2)

Followers

UpTweet

View the Original article